2022-2023 – Liberty Christian School-Argyle

2021-2022 – Grace Community School-Tyler

2020-2021 – Grace Community School-Tyler

2019-2020 – No award given due to COVID 19

2018-2019 – San Antonio Christian School

2017-2018 – San Antonio Christian School

2016-2017 – Grace Community School – Tyler

2015-2016 – Liberty Christian School – Argyle

2014-2015 – Liberty Christian School – Argyle

2013-2014 – Liberty Christian School – Argyle

2012-2013 – Liberty Christian School – Argyle

2011-2012 – Antonian College Preparatory School – San Antonio

2010-2011 – Antonian College Preparatory School – San Antonio

2009-2010 – Bishop Lynch High School – Dallas

2008-2009 – Bishop Lynch High School – Dallas

2007-2008 – Liberty Christian School – Argyle

2006-2007 – Liberty Christian School – Argyle

2005-2006 – Second Baptist School – Houston

2004-2005 (Tie) – Second Baptist School – Houston

2004-2005 (Tie) – Liberty Christian School – Denton

2003-2004 – Bishop Lynch High School – Dallas

2002-2003 – Bishop Lynch High School – Dallas

2001-2002 – Bishop Lynch High School – Dallas

2000-2001 – Bishop Lynch High School – Dallas

1999-2000 – Bishop Lynch High School – Dallas

1998-1999 – Trinity Christian Academy – Addison

1997-1998 – Bishop Lynch High School – Dallas

1996-1997 – Trinity Christian Academy – Addison